Friday, September 11, 2009

one mind, divided against itself, cannot stand?

this term, i teach my first class at 11am. there have been enough classes that i've noticed something:

whenever i work on research before heading off to teaching, my lectures become slightly erratic:
one day, it would be a persistent problem with missing negative (-) signs,

another day, it would be forgetting to discuss some arithmetic facts earlier in the lecture -- despite having arranged them carefully in my lecture notes -- and remembering only, in the midst of an example.

maybe my research self and my teaching self cannot co-exist peacefully!



on a related note, the last few mornings have been productive. each day i'm a little closer to proving this one theorem ..

Wednesday, September 09, 2009

eventually, you get the hard questions.

when i had worked as a TA, years ago, i deferred all the "hard" (that is, administrative) questions to the head instructor. there was even one prof who told me explicitly,

"i don't mind being the bad guy.
if students complain, send them to me.
"

as a graduate student, i might have run my own calculus class, but my students knew that i was nobody important. they didn't ask me the hard questions.

now i'm dr. so-&-so, the head instructor .. and there are always student emails in my in-box.

[sighs]

i suppose it happens to everyone, sooner or later.

Monday, September 07, 2009

ah .. geek humor. (:

"Jim Buckmaster is tall and thin, Newmark is short and round, and when they stand together they look like a binary number."

Saturday, September 05, 2009

an old memory: endings and beginnings.

by the time it turned august, 6 years ago, i was ready to move and start graduate school in mathematics. it was in my future. i was sure of it!

my bags and boxes were packed, fit neatly into the trunk and most of the backseat of a 4-door sedan. most of those were books, and of these, most of them i'd never read again; i didn't know how to plan very well, back then.

there was one last thing, before driving away: one last meeting with one of my profs, one last chat about ideas and research.



it had been an eventful summer for me, full of new travels. those were my first conferences; he had suggested them. i learned a lot. among other lessons, i discovered that i truly knew nothing.

sometimes i hated being right. (i had my suspicions.)

i hadn't seen that prof since may, but upon walking into his office and greeting him, that gap of time seemed utterly imagined. he asked me about finland and about utah, whom i had met there, what i thought about the kinds of analysis that i've seen.

even in that last hour, i still learned a few last intuitions. i confessed that i understood very little and asked him a handful of the things that i didn't know.

so we talked mathematics for a while.

after a while, he cautioned me: "where you're going, they're very geometric, very abstract. make sure you always know the beginnings of the theory, the motivations. always ask!"

i nodded.

a moment passed, and then he asked, "they're not going to make you take algebraιc geometry there, are they? it's not one of the required first-year courses?"

i assured him no, but i learned later that it wasn't a silly question. that would be true for half the students i'd meet in grad school, but not for me.

i had an agenda, you see.
i was determined to become an analyst.



before my ph.d.,
before i had an advisor,
i had a mentor.

there was never any formal agreement, just some unspoken understanding. he always listened, he offered before i could ask; he still does. without him, i doubt i'd have become a mathematician.

so, for those profs, postdocs, or instructors who interact often with undergrads: your mentoring matters.

it's frustrating, i imagine. undergrads, american or otherwise, aren't especially known for their professionalism.

for a few of us, though, it's made all the difference.

Tuesday, September 01, 2009

it's nice to know that i'm not alone in my postdoc confusion.

except for the wife & child, i can imagine myself saying the same thing ..


from Ph.D. Comics by Jorgε Cham.

Monday, August 31, 2009

in which mathεmatical ρroof is like the story of goldilocks ..

a week ago, i tried to prove one particular fact,
but my argument was too weak. i needed a lemma.

some days ago, i worked out the lemma and obtained a proof.

yesterday i looked at the proof again.
adjusting it carefully, it gives a stronger result.

today i looked at the result. it's too strong.
i think i can find a counter-example ..

.. which means, of course, that the proof is wrong.
i'll let you know if the next proof is "just right."



in other news, today were my first lectures of the fall. i was pleased to find the classrooms easily enough.

you see, a year ago i couldn't remember the room number. so i guessed at random, found a classroom full of calculus students, and summarily began my lecture.

Saturday, August 29, 2009

not much to say, so i will plagiarise:

there is a haiku by kobayashi issa which sums up how i feel about mathematics today:

Napped half the day;
no one
punished me!


maybe tomorrow will be a more productive day.

Thursday, August 27, 2009

pedagogical thoughts.

this term i'm teaching calcu1us 2. i thought myself ambitious when i thought to change the order of topics in the first week of lectures, from

monday/wednesday: methods of integraτion (e.g. substitution, parts)
friday: numerical integraτion

to instead:

monday: riεmann sums, numerical integraτion
wednesday/friday: methods of integraτion

as for my reasoning: upon completing a calc 1 course at this university, students are supposed to have learned about Riεmann sums and methods of integration.

even in the ideal situation, that they actually learned and understood these things at the time,

  1. it's been 3-4 months of summer;
    it can't hurt to remind them of what a riεmann sum is;

  2. even if they took calc 1 as a summer course, they would have either learned it very briefly (6-week course) or hadn't seen the definition in some time (12-week course).

then again, i have my own prejudices:

mathematics isn't just about manipulations of funny symbols. behind the notation are meaningful objects and ideas.

if we're going to talk about Rιemann integrals in this course, then i want a student to know what a Rιemann integral is.




as it happens: at an educational level, there are far more ambitious instructors than me.

it never occurred to me, but after reading this post from Learning Curves,

there isn't much to stop an instructor from teaching sequences, infinite series, and taylor series first, and then proceeding to integration and applications.

from my own experience, most students have trouble with series. it might be a good idea to cover it early, so that they have more time to digest the material .. maybe even get to know it well.

on the other hand, imagine this complaint:

if you teach students about taylor expansions --

.. and let's face it, in calculus courses we only give students "calculator functions" that do have such series expansions ..

-- then the computation of any definite integral boils down to using the taylor series, integrating term by term, and using the fundamenτal theorem. [1]

so what would be the point of learning these methods of integration?

[1] admittedly, yes: switching the order of summation and integration requires some analysis, but it's not like we teach that kind of thing in calcu1us anyway.

Tuesday, August 25, 2009

on mathematics blogs.

i had started drafting this last week, probably as a reaction to j.baez's post about "what a mathematician should know about blogging."

this is what i concluded about my own writing on this blog.



after some thought, i realised something. this is not a mathematics blog. rather, this is a mathematical culture blog of a highly idiosyncratic nature.

in contrast, these are mathematical blogs, as popularised by t.tao.

interestingly enough, the associated wiki seems to be using the arXiv:math style of categorization. i suppose a blog now has to be something serious and have a specific topic.

maybe blogs are going the way of the webpage. they used to exist mostly for fun, but somehow transformed into a professional tool. as for where the fun can go, now ..

my purpose here is not to educate -- at least, not in the sense of writing a lecture and posting it in a mix of HTML and LaTeX.

if i learn a cool theorem, i'll share it.

however, i'll also avoid the long expositions that are pages 1-4 of research papers or the first section of a textbook chapter.

you see, i like my job a lot. i voluntarily work most nights. i like maths ..

.. but i don't want to read technical mathematics all the time. the idioms of "definition, lemma, proof, example, theorem .." makes for very good learning and research ..

.. but i have enough papers to read.

i'm not the sort of person who, returning home from work, runs a web search to look for more of this stuff. instead, i get to it tomorrow morning.



as for what this blog's purpose is, let's just say entertainment value, perhaps catharsis, too.

if my teaching goes oddly one day, at least you the reader can have a laugh about it, as long as i write well enough.

if my research isn't going well, then maybe you can relate. then again, it might make your workday look better in comparison. i don't mind.

Sunday, August 23, 2009

when misdirections go awry.

yesterday i had just run a race and was idling at the finish line, eating a bagel.

a young man, standing next to me, nods to me. i nod back. we get to talking, and he asks me what i do.

"i teach math," i replied. [1]

his friends also teach math. "which grade?" i ask. (they teach at a liberal arts college.) eventually i ask him what his job is.

"oh, i'm a physics postdoc at cmu."

argh!
i should have just said that i was a post-doc.



[1] which is true. most non-academics i've encountered do not know what a post-doc is, and "i'm a mathematician" conversations get a little boring after a while.

it's not unlike telling someone that i have 8 fingers. as it happens, i have as many as 10, but it remains true that i have 8.